;

Voting in the Crypt: Why Goa’s Elections Feel Hollow

Every few years Goa holds elections. Candidates swear loyalty in a temple, holy cross and other sacred places . Voters stand in queues, press a button on the EVM, and walk out believing that they have chosen their representatives. Then, within months or a couple of years, many of those same representatives cross the floor to the ruling party. In 2019, ten of fifteen Congress MLAs switched to the BJP. In 2022, eight of eleven did the same. The pattern is so familiar that many Goans now enter the polling booth already half-expecting their vote to be emptied out.

Most commentary explains this through the anti-defection law’s loopholes, money, or weak party discipline. Those factors matter, but they do not capture the deeper feeling that settles over the state before every election: a quiet, collective exhaustion. To understand that feeling we need a different kind of reading, one that looks beneath the surface language of democracy and listens for what has been buried.

Psychoanalysts Nicolas Abraham and Mária Török described a psychological structure they called the crypt. When a loss or betrayal is too painful or shameful to face openly, the mind does not mourn it. Instead it swallows the experience whole and seals it inside a secret vault. The person continues living, but part of their psychic life remains locked away, influencing everything without ever being spoken. Nicholas Rand and Esther Rashkin later showed how this same structure can operate in language and in social life. Words can become cryptonyms, terms that sound ordinary while concealing a violence, pain or a secret.

Read this way, the Goan polling booth might appear to become a psychic crypt.

On the surface, the act of voting is empowerment. You choose. You exercise agency. Anasemically, reading upstream against the ordinary meaning, the Electronic Voting Machine functions more like a sealed tomb. The voter deposits political will into a dark chamber without knowing whether that will will survive. Because wholesale defections have happened repeatedly, even after public oaths, the ballot is cast under the shadow of anticipatory grief. People already suspect their choice is being entombed before the new Assembly has settled into its term.

The constitutional term “two-thirds merger” is the perfect cryptonym. Legally it refers to a collective, recognised joining of parties under the Tenth Schedule. In practice it has become the preferred vehicle for individual legislators to carry their seats into the ruling dispensation. When an elected representative crosses over, something more than a party label changes. The institutional power that the ballot conferre access to ministries, state resources, protection, is absorbed by the new party. The vote itself is left as an empty shell. The electorate holds the outer form of a democratic exercise while the living kernel of sovereignty has been quietly transferred to the very force many voters tried to reject.

Local language already has a name for the figure who performs this leap: the jumping frog, udki marpi. The legislator who springs from opposition benches into the ruling side for personal or ministerial gain. Esther Rashkin’s work on narrative figures possessed by unspoken histories is useful here. The jumping frog is not merely an opportunistic individual. He or she is the visible symptom of a recurring political phantom, an unresolved history of betrayal that keeps repeating across election cycles. When the defector explains the move with phrases about “development of the constituency” or claims divine permission after breaking a sacred oath, the speech becomes a kind of ventriloquism. The language of public service is spoken aloud, while the unspoken drive of transactional survival dictates the action. The candidate no longer represents the constituent. The candidate becomes an avatar of pure self-preservation.

A democratic mandate rests on an invisible moral contract: the belief that a promise made to voters carries ethical weight. In Abraham and Török’s terms, that moral bond is part of what keeps a social body coherent. When defections are normalised, rewarded with cabinet posts, and left unresolved in years-long legal processes, the moral power of the mandate steadily drains away. The five-year term starts to feel like a commercial lease that can be sublet to the highest bidder once the election is over. Cynicism follows. Citizens shift from active participants to spectators of their own disenfranchisement. Hope becomes something people perform rather than something they inhabit.

Anasemic analysis is not only diagnostic. Its purpose is decryptionbringing the buried secret into the open so that genuine mourning and renewal become possible. As long as each election is treated as an isolated event, and as long as voters continue to hope that temple oaths or party symbols alone will bind a candidate, the crypt remains sealed and the cycle repeats.

Breaking it open requires clearer naming. The structural betrayal must be spoken without euphemism. Political jumping frogs should not be casually rehabilitated in the next election cycle. Institutional accountability must be demanded where legal loopholes currently protect opportunism. The point is not purity. Politics will always involve compromise. The point is to refuse the complete emptying of the vote.

The kernel that matters is simple and stubborn: a vote whose power belongs permanently to the people who cast it, not to the individual who temporarily carries it. When that kernel is recovered, the polling booth can stop functioning as a tomb and begin to function again as a place of living choice. Until then, Goans will keep walking into the crypt, pressing a button, and waiting to see whether anything they deposited will still be breathing when the next term begins.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

;