;

The Shell Without the Kernel: Goa’s Hollowed Politics

There is a strange thing that happens when a word is repeated too often. It loses its meaning and becomes only a sound. Say “BJP” in Goa today, or say “Congress”, and listen carefully. What comes back is not an ideology, not a programme, not even a memory of struggle. It is an echo. The two names still stand on our hoardings and our ballot papers, but something inside them has gone missing. To understand what has gone missing, I want to borrow a strange word from psychoanalysis: anasemia.

The Hungarian-French analysts Nicolas Abraham and Maria Torok used this term to describe a peculiar movement of language. An anasemic word does not point forward to a meaning; it points backward, beneath meaning, to the hidden source from which meaning once came. Abraham gave us a beautiful image for this: the shell and the kernel. Every concept has a visible shell, the part we speak about and argue over, and an invisible kernel, the living core that gives the shell its shape. When the kernel dies, the shell does not collapse at once. It goes on standing, perfectly intact, like an empty coconut that still looks whole on the tree. Goa’s two national parties are today such shells.

Let us begin with the BJP, because it is the party that has won. Under Manohar Parrikar, whatever one thought of his politics, the Goa BJP had a kernel. It was a cadre party built slowly, booth by booth, by workers who believed they were offering Goa an alternative to what they called the culture of Congress: the fiefdoms, the family seats, the trading of MLAs like cashew at the market. That promise of being different was the kernel. And then the party began to import the very thing it had defined itself against. In 2019, ten of the fifteen Congress MLAs crossed over. In 2022, eight more followed, though they had sworn before God in a temple, a church and a dargah that they would never leave. When the Sawant government was sworn in that year, only two of its nine ministers came from the original BJP. The rest had been Congressmen. Today the BJP sits with 27 MLAs in a House of 40, a number that would have made the old cadre dance, if only so many of those 27 were theirs.
This is what I call the Congressification of the BJP. It is not merely that former Congressmen now wear saffron scarves. It is that the logic of Congress, the politics of the fief lord who owns his constituency and carries it with him from party to party, has entered the BJP and become its working method. The ticket now goes to the one who can win, not the one who carried the flag in the rain. Former Chief Minister Laxmikant Parsekar said openly that the party had not grown because of the imports. Old workers complain at every election that they are asked to campaign for the very men they once campaigned against. The shell of the BJP has grown larger than ever. The kernel, the cadre’s belief in being different, has been quietly buried.

Here Abraham and Torok give us another idea, the crypt. When a loss cannot be mourned openly, they said, the psyche does not let it go. It builds a secret tomb inside itself and keeps the dead one there, alive and unspoken. The Goa BJP carries such a crypt. Parrikar is invoked at every function and his photograph hangs in every office, but the party cannot speak honestly about what died with him, because to mourn him properly would be to admit how far it has travelled from him. So the dead leader becomes, in Torok’s language, a phantom: a presence that haunts the living without ever being named. Every time a defector is garlanded at the party office, the phantom stirs.

Now turn to the Congress, which has been hollowed in a different and perhaps more painful way. The BJP’s shell has been filled with foreign matter. The Congress has been emptied of matter altogether. A party that once ruled Goa almost as a natural right was reduced, after the 2022 split, to three MLAs. Its kernel was never ideology in the strict sense; it was the network of local strongmen who gave it a body in every taluka. Those strongmen are now in the BJP. What remains in the Congress is the name, the history, a loyal vote among minorities and the old faithful, and a handful of leaders trying to hold the shell together. Even now, as the 2027 election approaches, the party has changed its state president again, bringing back Girish Chodankar, and voices within, including South Goa MP Viriato Fernandes, have complained that it was imposed without consultation at the grassroots. The Congress promises that no defector will get a ticket in 2027. It is a brave vow, but vows are exactly what Goan voters have learned not to trust.

So we arrive at the true crisis, which is a crisis of leadership on both sides. The BJP has power without a soul it can name, and its leaders compete as rival fief lords under one flag. The Congress has a soul it can name but very little body left to carry it. Neither can produce a leader who stands for something larger than his own constituency. And the smaller forces, the RGP with its nativist fire, AAP, the Goa Forward of Vijai Sardesai, are either fighting each other or fighting themselves. The RGP has just lost its founder-president Manoj Parab to an internal revolt.

What, then, is the Goan voter to do? Here the anasemic reading becomes very practical. If the party name has become a shell, then voting for a symbol is like praying to an empty tabernacle. The voter who chooses Congress fears that her vote will walk across the road to the BJP within two years, as it did twice before. The voter who chooses the BJP wonders whether he is voting for the party of Parrikar or for the Congressman who was once its enemy. Many, tired of both, are tempted to stay home or to scatter their votes among small parties, which, as everyone in Goa knows, often helps the strongest party most. This is the dilemma: every choice feels like a choice between shells.

It would be unfair not to hear the other side. BJP leaders will say that stability and development matter more than purity, that Goa got bridges, highways and a government that did not fall every few months, and that people join a party because they want to work with it. Congress leaders will say that being emptied is also an opportunity, that a party stripped of its fief lords can finally rebuild around ideas and young people. Both arguments deserve to be weighed honestly at the ballot box.

But if Abraham and Torok teach us anything, it is that a hollow can only be healed when we look inside it and name what was lost. For the BJP, that means admitting that winning every MLA is not the same as winning Goa. For the Congress, it means building a kernel of conviction strong enough that its legislators will not sell it. And for us voters, it means looking past the shell, past the symbol on the machine, to the person, the record and the promise kept. The Party that looks whole and complete may be already fragmented In 2027, Goa will have to shake it and listen, discern and choose .

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

;